(Aka: A little thoughtful thinking for you A.)
Pop music is a subtle and uncertain art. Often declassified by hardcore music fans as “too easy”, for its incline on catchy tunes, light-hearted melodies and sweet-love lyrics, a closer look reveals how much of this is generally built on repetitive listening of average pop songs. Forgive my caricaturing but I’m trying to make a point here. See, the greatest pop songs may often fit in this description, but will almost as often reveal themselves unforgettable.
It appears that the greatest subtlety of (at least modern) pop music is to manage to reach out to the broadest audience using the catchiest tunes and still keep something to discover for the fewer, more exigent, often most critical part of the listeners. It requires some cunning and some stunts. I requires pulling off unseen tricks, surprising everybody will remaining very accessible. The Beatles managed it for years, so did the Beach Boys, and both of them are now more remembered for their riskiest albums (Sgt Pepper’s Lonely Heart Club Band or Pet Sounds) than for their debut recordings.
The Do seemed to have gotten it right, at first. Their first single hit the target perfectly. Beginning with weird – yet unaggressive – guitar feedbacks, meshed with an upbeat tempo on the drum/bass and a melodic singing voice building into a steady full-bodied verse with the song unfolding an almost too obvious fashion from there on, On My Shoulders seemed to cry out the name of a soon-to-remember, soon-to-be innovative, band. Instead, their album appears to be slightly less-good than the debut single. If not disappointing.
I mean, everything is here: The slightly lo-fi sound (yet perfectly mixed), the somewhat folkish use of the guitars, up to the small imperfections sprinkled from here to there. BUT, something is definitely lacking. In every features of the album, everything is “expected”, and they’re not missing out, BUT, the case is: it’s not really surprising. After a few song even the mellow charm of singer’s Olivia B.Merilahti’s voice wears out, the rythms, the feedbacks, it all seems a bit overdone and you start to ponder whether you’re gonna listen to the rest of it or skip directly to the next song.
That is not good. Definitely not good.
Not unbearable yet, but when one, accidentally falls into Panda Bear‘s (the escaped beast from Animal Collective) last E.P Person Pitch, one starts to wonder whether there wasn’t something wrong with The Do all along. As for me, the comparison is harsh, the later don’t stand a chance against the former. That is the magic of good Pop music, suddenly it appears crystal clear that one of the bands is trying too hard, attempting to sound like Pop whereas the other one is making Pop music the way it’s supposed to be felt: In a fun way.
Panda Bear is actually quite unsettling. It’s really not something you would expect, even from a member of Animal Collective. Basically, it’s a guy, alone, sampling songs, beats and chords in a dazzling maze of sounds, joy & fury (yes I added joy, cause this is definitely furiously joyful), and chanting – not singing, chanting – over it. All that in a weird, dancy, Brian Wilson-esque fashion that’s both uncanny and seducive. It’s almost as hard to describe as it is to understand, and it’s as hard to classify as it is to skip.
To sum it up, it needs to be discovered.
Because somewhere, Noah Lennox’s got it. He found the underlying idea of great pop, that it should be both fun and innovative, totally listen-able and unheard. And I’m pretty sure, even if he doesn’t keep on with this side project he’ll have had some influence on the next pop recordings to come up, at least for the rest of this decade. Because he has now joined the official brotherhood of Pop smart-asses kids. Praise be to the Bro’s!
Panda Bear – Bro’s